Ether Explained - Chapter 5: Ether Classic (ETC) vs. Ether (ETH)
30 July 2019Reading time: 6 minutes
Vontobel
now offers investors access to the crypto currency «Ether». But what is Ether?
And why has the second best-known crypto currency gained so much popularity in
such a short time? In eight chapters, we want to give you high-quality
knowledge about the exciting topic of «Ether».
After the DAO hacker attack the community decided to carry out a so called
«hard fork». From Ethereum two different crypto currencies emerged: Ethereum
Classic (ETC), which still stuck to the old Ethereum blockchain and Ethereum
(ETH), which was separated from the original blockchain and now exists
independently from ETC. This was followed by an ideological and ethical battle
between the two crypto currencies. Let's take a closer look at the reasons why
there is Ethereum on one side and Ethereum Classic on the other.
Ethereum vs. Ethereum Classic
Those
who were against the Hard Fork decided to stay with the original Blockchain,
which they called Ethereum Classic (ETC). The market capitalisation for ETC is
currently USD 0.6 billion*, the 21st largest crypto currency in CoinMarketCap's
crypto ranking. According to Kraken, you have to pay USD 6.15* for an ETC. The
new blockchain kept the name Ethereum (ETH). It is the better-known crypto
currency and currently has a price of USD 208.89* for one ETH. The market
capitalisation for ETH is currently USD 22 billion* and is therefore in second
place in the cryptro ranking.

Advantages Ethereum Classic
So why did people stick to an old blockchain when all the well-known
Ethereum supporters, including the founders Vitalik Buterin and Gavin Wood,
moved to the new blockchain? The answer is more philosophical. In their
opinion, once a code standard has been set, it should not be changed («Code is
law»). The blockchain is therefore untouchable and should not be changed,
regardless of the outcome. Once the blockchain has been modified, you have to
do it again and again if there are difficulties. The blockchain has been made
unchangeable so that the system is resistant to human moods. But they criticize
that the blockchain was nevertheless influenced by human moods. And this has triggered
resistance among many «crypto idealists».
Ethereum Classic still has a hard time getting past its «mother» Ethereum,
but with 21th place in the crypto currency ranking, ETC is still at the upper
range. System improvements have also been made at Ethereum Classic. Significant
innovations such as even greater decentralization are intended to prevent
concealment, corruption, inefficiency and stagnation in the future. Although
the operators believe in the original, a disaster like the one in 2016 cannot
be repeated, according to the creators of Ethereum Classic. They want to
develop more freely, more transparently and openly for discourse in the future.
There should be no more transactions behind closed doors.
Disadvantages Ethereum Classic
The main problem with the ETC is the lack of downward compatibility with
the Ethereum hard fork. All the famous supporters of the Ethereum community
have joined the new ETH blockchain. Anyone who participates in the ETC also has
no access to ETH updates. The best example of this is the change of ETH from
Proof-of-Work (PoW) to Proof-of-Stake (PoS). ETC will not be able to implement
this because its software does not allow these updates.
At the moment, Ethereum Classic still lacks comprehensive external
financing. In malicious forums, ETC is sometimes described as a speculative
object or even fraudulent. Many even consider ETC an attack on Ethereum itself:
Prominent bloggers like David Seaman have reported that «Classic is an insecure
orphan chain being promoted in a way that would be illegal if Ethereum were a
publicly traded company.»
Advantages Ethereum
ETH was founded for a single reason: to return the stolen Ether from the
DAO hacker to its legal owners (the DAO token holders). It is also a victory
for the Ethereum community: It has overcome the worst hack in the history of
crypto currencies and formed a network that is stronger than its predecessor.
ETH is also undergoing the most revolutionary changes (such as the
aforementioned change from PoW to PoS).
It is true that the hard fork speaks against the immutability of the
blockchain, but the circumstances for the modification must be taken into
account. The DAO attack stole a third of the DAO's Ether supply, which in turn
accounted for 14% of the total amount of Ether. Therefore, it is dangerous to surrender
such a large amount of Ether to a malicious attacker. After this attack,
something had to be done to ensure that justice was preserved. This is exactly
what the hard fork has achieved. Not only did it devalue the Ether the attacker
had in his possession, but it also compensated every DAO token holder.
Therefore, the concerns that this could be the beginning of many hard forks are
pointless, because the Ethereum community is decentralized and democratic. Such
essential decisions can only be made if the majority of the network agrees.
Moreover, Ethereum is still at a very early stage where mistakes can happen
that can be corrected at a later stage. In addition, the rescue operation
protects investors from legal action and prevents regulatory intervention.
ETH is growing exponentially and has the majority of supporters who have
produced Ethereum on its side. ETH is backed by a group of 270 companies called
the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance (EEA). It aims to establish smart contracts
with Fortune 500 companies using blockchain technology. In addition, the new
version is constantly updated with the latest updates.
Disadvantages Ethereum
But ETH also has its ideological problems. In the eyes of the anti-ETH
people, the advocates of ETH should have accepted the main blockchain as what
it was - even after the hack. Moreover, how can you be sure that in the future
there will be no more hard forks that are subject to human moods? What if there
are several hard forks that create different versions of Ethereum? What if
hundreds of different versions of Ethereum are kept alive at the same time?
Will this not lead to a strong devaluation, even for crypto currencies in
general?
Conclusion: Ethereum is far
ahead of Ethereum Classic
After the DAO hack, Ethereum's reputation suffered massively. However, ETH
is proof of what the Ethereum community is capable of. It faced a severe
disaster, stuck together and found an elegant solution. Ethereum is not just a
currency, but a platform on which projects can be built. If decentralization is
indeed the future, then Ethereum will be at the forefront. ETH has all the
leading developers like founder Vitalik Buterin at its side. The value of a
currency results from the trust that people place in it, and due to all these
factors the trust in ETH will only grow. Many experts even predict that ETH
will be the first crypto currency since Bitcoin to break the USD 1,000
threshold in the future.
Unfortunately, this cannot be said for ETC. Some claim that ETC will always
be the "black sheep" of the Ethereum family. At the moment ETH is
almost 34 times more valuable than ETC. Moreover, the fact that ETC is known to
be fraudulent only reduces the trust people have in ETC, which in turn reduces
its value. However, ETC decided to keep their blockchain and develop further.
That is the beauty of the blockchain mechanism and free -market capitalism.
*As of 30 July 2019
Important Notice:
This
information is neither an investment advice nor an investment or investment
strategy recommendation, but advertisement. The complete information on the
securities, in particular the structure and risks associated with an investment,
are described in the base prospectus, together with any supplements, as well as
the final terms. The base prospectus and final terms constitute the sole
binding sales documents for the securities. It is recommended that potential
investors read these documents before making any investment decision in order
to fully understand the potential risks and rewards of deciding to invest in
the securities. The documents and the key information document are published on
the website of the issuer on prospectus.vontobel.com and are available from the
issuer free of charge. The approval of the prospectus should not be understood
as an endorsement of the securities. The
securities are products that are not simple and may be difficult to understand.
This information contains an indication of past performance. Past performance
is not a reliable indicator of future results.
This
document and the information contained in it may only be distributed or
published in countries where such distribution or publication is permitted by
applicable law. As stated in the relevant base prospectus, the distribution of
the securities mentioned in this information is subject to restrictions in
certain jurisdictions. This advertisement may not be reproduced or
redistributed without Vontobel’s permission.
More thematic investments
27/06/2022 20:32:57